top of page

What Suppliers are Not Telling Us about Activated Carbon Filters

Nov 2, 2023
3 min read

Updated: 4 days ago


As Water Treatment Specialists we like to accentuate the positives of the activated carbon filters that we sell and install. In Water Conditioning more knowledge equals better water, it is that simple. What we (meaning our industry as a whole) don't talk about enough is that carbon alone is insufficient to remove some organic contaminants. Testing for some of these takes certified labs, and those tests cost money, which is why some companies are reluctant to bring it up with a new prospect.



I get it. We have all arrived for an estimate and found another uniformed guy from a different company leaving the home. It can feel like your time isn't being valued. It isn't, deal with it. The prospect accepted a free estimate and owed you nothing more. The estimate is not free for you; it is included in our costs and price points.


Given this reality, it is not hard to imagine being tempted, under financial pressure, to cut corners to win more sales. Commissioned salespeople are especially prone to it. One manifestation: a Treatment Specialist skips the costly help of local laboratories. Frankly, that is grossly negligent and unfair. People depend on us to help ensure safe drinking water for their families. The best prospect is an informed prospect!


The best practice is as follows: Provide full disclosure and let the homeowner decide on the range of testing that will be used to determine water conditioning.


So here it is the bombshell: While activated carbon is effective at removing many organic contaminants, there are certain pesticides and herbicides that it may struggle to remove completely. Some examples of pesticides and herbicides that may require supplemental treatment include:


1. Glyphosate: Glyphosate is a widely used herbicide in agriculture and landscaping. It can be challenging to remove completely using activated carbon, as its molecular structure makes it less adsorbable.


2. Atrazine: Atrazine is a commonly used herbicide in agricultural settings. It is persistent and can pose challenges for complete removal with activated carbon alone.


3. 2,4-Dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D): 2,4-D is a herbicide widely used for weed control. While activated carbon can remove some 2,4-D, it may not be fully effective in removing it, especially in higher concentrations.


4. Imidacloprid: Imidacloprid is a systemic insecticide used in agriculture and horticulture. Due to its chemical properties, complete removal with activated carbon alone can be challenging, requiring additional treatment methods.


In cases where these pesticides or herbicides are of concern, additional treatment methods such as advanced oxidation processes, reverse osmosis, or biological degradation may be necessary to achieve complete removal. So if you propose an activated charcoal filter as a stand-alone device, remember that such herbicides and pesticides may be present. It is good practice to outsource tests to the certified laboratory performing them daily. It is good if you can have this third party, people who practice "generally accepted scientific methodology" squarely in your corner. At a minimum, you need to know what contaminants might be present to design an effective water treatment train. Anything less is negligence. We are dealing with people's water, folks, let's get it together.


Sadly, it is the customers themselves who, although informed of the risks, decide to cut costs and forego such tests. One series of tests carries a real cost. If there are a variety of concerns, it might take a few different labs to get the full picture. All we can do in the practice of applied science is be transparent and try to protect the health and safety of our clients as best as we can under the circumstances.

Keep reading

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
bottom of page